The East African Court of Justice in Arusha Tanzania on Friday July 31 started hearing a case in which a Ugandan journalist, the late Ssembuusi Ronald, challenged criminal defamation.
A panel of five Judges led by the Principal Judge of the Court, Justice Monica Mugenyi presided over the hearing in the First Instance Court.
The late Ssembuusi, who passed on in January this year is represented by Catherine Anite and Nicholas Opiyo of Oasis Advocates while the Attorney General of Uganda is represented by State Attorneys Jeffrey Atwine, Harriet Nalukenge and Ojambo Bichachi.
Ssembuusi, a former CBS FM radio correspondent in Kalangala district died in January 2015 after filing his case with the EACJ.
His lawyer, Catherine Anite, told journalists in Arusha that his death did not affect the case because the Rules of the Court allow for the appointment of a legal representative.
During the hearing, it sufficed that the Rules of the Court are unclear on how to notify Court about the death of a complainant and how to join the legal representative of the deceased to the suit.
Ssembuusi’s lawyers wrote a letter to the Registrar of the Court about the death of their client and the duly appointed representative.
But Court, using its discretional powers, directed them to file a motion substituting the deceased with the duly appointed legal representative.
Court was adjourned to allow Ssembuusi’s lawyers to finalize the process.
Meanwhile, the United Nations, African Union, Media Legal Defence Initiative-London and nineteen other civil society organizations have filed applications at the East African Court of Justice seeking to intervene in the case.
In their joint application filed at the Arusha Court on July 30th, both the UN Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression, David Kaye and AU Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression and Access to Information, Faith Dikeledi Pansy Tlakula said they will provide Court with expert interpretation on international law from the perspective of the AU and UN.
“The Special Rapporteurs will provide insight as to how the AU and UN define the appropriate contours of government restrictions on speech and press in the context of defamation laws, and will assist the Court in assessing the Statute’s compatibility with the principles enshrined in the EAC Treaty,” stated Kaye and Pansy in their application.
The Media Legal Defence Initiative based in London and nineteen others in their application filed on July 10th stated that they have a strong interest in the case because it raises questions concerning the permissible limits on the right to freedom of expression including freedom of the press and the right to access information.
The AU and UN are represented by Tanzanian Advocate William Ernest while MLDI and 19 others are represented by Senior Lawyer, Gimara Francis.
In December 2014, Ssembuusi (now deceased) filed a case in the East Court of Justice challenging his conviction and one year jail term sentence by the Kalangala Magistrates Court on charges of criminal defamation.
Ssembuusi in his affidavit contends that the continued use by the Uganda government of sections 179 and 180 of the Penal Code Act of Uganda which provide for the offence of criminal defamation is a violation of the fundamental and operating principles of the East African Community Treaty.
He wants Court to determine whether or not these sections of the Penal Code Act place justifiable restrictions on the right to freedom of expression, media and access to information that are protected by the Treaty for Establishment of East African Community.
The organizations say the impact of the EACJ’s decision will go beyond Uganda’s boarders and that is why it is important for them to assist the Court in assessing Ssembuusi’s case.
“This is very encouraging, we hope the court will accept the request and allow these organizations and individuals to contribute towards enriching the jurisprudence of freedom of expression and the media in Uganda,” said Robert Ssempala, the National Coordinator, Human Rights Network for Journalists-Uganda.